Comparative Legal Lessons from the 2015 and 2024 Riau Islands Gubernatorial Elections
DOI:
Abstract
This study examines the persistent challenge of regulatory fragmentation in Indonesia’s decentralized electoral governance through a comparative legal analysis of the 2015 and 2024 gubernatorial elections in Riau Islands Province. Using a juridical-comparative approach combined with doctrinal legal analysis and process tracing, the research compares statutory frameworks, institutional coordination, and electoral outcomes. Data were drawn from official regulations, Provincial KPU reports, voter turnout statistics, and budget records. Findings show that while the 2024 election benefited from greater legal coherence than in 2015, unchecked subnational discretion most notably the reduction of polling stations from 4,654 to 3,327 resulted in lower voter turnout (77% to 54%) and reduced accessibility, particularly in remote archipelagic areas. The study argues that both normative misalignment and procedural discretion, when unbounded, undermine electoral inclusiveness and transparency. Theoretically, this article contributes to the discourse on legal pluralism and regulatory coherence by demonstrating how harmonization must integrate both legal standardization and procedural predictability. Practically, it proposes a unified Election Code, “bounded discretion” guidelines, and institutionalized inter-agency coordination to safeguard electoral integrity.
Downloads
Views : 110
Downloads : 42
References
A. Riwanto, Hukum Partai Politik dan Hukum Pemilu di Indonesia: Pengaruhnya terhadap Penyelenggaraan Pemilu Berkualitas dan Sistem Pemerintahan Presidensial Efektif. Surakarta: ThafaMedia, 2022.
E. S. Hiariej, Hukum Pemilu Indonesia, Jakarta: RajaGrafindo Persada, 2022.
D. Heilmann, W. Ekatjahjana, and K. Hauerstein (Eds.), Regulatory Reform in Indonesia: A Legal Perspective. Jakarta: Hanns Seidel Foundation in cooperation with Directorate General of Legislation, Ministry of Law and Human Rights, 2019.
F. Testriono, Persistence of Power and Subnational Democratic Performance: The Case of Indonesia, Ph.D. dissertation, Dept. Political Science, Northern Illinois Univ., DeKalb, IL, USA, 2022.
B. Muhtadi, Vote Buying in Indonesia: The Mechanics of Electoral Bribery. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan, 2019.
K. Ambardi, Mengungkap Politik Kartel: Studi tentang Sistem Kepartaian di Indonesia Era Reformasi. Jakarta: Kepustakaan Populer Gramedia, 2009.
N. Trenggono, Dinamika Penyelenggaraan Pemilu dan Pilkada di Indonesia: Catatan Reflektif Ketua KPU Provinsi se‑Indonesia. Yogyakarta: Asnalitera, 2018.
B. Z. Tamanaha, Legal Pluralism Explained: History, Theory and Consequences. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2021.
J. Baker, “Reformasi Reversal: Structural Drivers of Democratic Decline in Jokowi’s Middle‑Income Indonesia,” Bull. Indonesian Econ. Study., vol. 59, no. 3, pp. 341–364, Dec. 2023.
S. Marzuki, “The Roles of General Election Commission and General Election Supervisory Board for a Democratic Election,” Jurnal Hukum IUS QUIA IUSTUM, vol. 15, no. 3, Jun. 2009.
Komisi Pemilihan Umum, Dinamika Hukum Pemilu: Problematika dan Implementasi Produk Hukum KPU, Jakarta: Komisi Pemilihan Umum, Cet. I, 2022.
M. Hassan, H. Larreguy, and S. Russell, “Who Gets Hired? Political Patronage and Bureaucratic Favoritism,” Am. Polit. Sci. Rev., vol. 118, no. 4, pp. 1913–1930, Jan. 2024.
United Cities and Local Governments & World Bank, Decentralization and Local Democracy in the World: First Global Report (GOLD I), Barcelona & Washington, DC: UCLG/World Bank, 2008.
D. Azfirmawarman, H. Naldi, A. Frinaldi, and L. Magriasti, “Analisis demokrasi pada era desentralisasi dalam perspektif administrasi publik,” Jurnal Ilmu Administrasi dan Kebijakan Publik, vol. 27, no. 2, Des. 2024.
Y. Chandra, “Assessing the Impact of Decentralization on the Quality of Indonesian Democracy,” Global Strategis, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 409–430, Oct. 2024.
D. Prayogo and I. Ruwaida (Eds.), Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Social and Political Issues: “Rethinking Nationalism: Looking Back and Looking Forward, Sanur (Bali), 29–30 Oct. 2018.
L. Marcoes, L. Lusandiana, and N. Srikandi (Eds.), Demokrasi dan Pandemi: Bunga Rampai Pengetahuan Masyarakat Sipil di Indonesia. Jakarta: Perhimpunan Pengembangan Media Nusantara (CIVICA), 2021.
S. Sumardi, Pengantar Ilmu Pemerintahan: Konsep, Teori, dan Aplikasinya. Yogyakarta: Tahta Media Group, 2025.
S. Zuhro et al., Dinamika Demokrasi, Pemilu dan Otonomi Daerah di Indonesia, Yogyakarta: Leutika Prio, 2022.
M. Romli and A. Faidi, “Urgensi reformasi Pilkada: Strategi penguatan demokrasi lokal di era desentralisasi,” Jurnal Ilmiah Ilmu Pemerintahan, vol. 13, no. 1, 2025.
B. Hutapea, “Dinamika Hukum Pemilihan Kepala Daerah di Indonesia,” J. Rechts Vinding: Media Pembinaan Hukum Nas., vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 1–20, Apr. 2015.
M. H. Ansori et al, Post‑Conflict Democracy, Violence, and Peace‑Building in Aceh and Maluku, National Violence Monitoring System (NVMS/SNPK), The Habibie Center, Jakarta, 2015.
A. Dugaswara, “Harmonisasi Peraturan KPU dan Peraturan Perundang‑Undangan Lainnya demi Terciptanya Azas Kepastian Hukum,” Electoral Review & Evaluation, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 1–18, Apr. 2019.
Komisi Informasi Pusat, Jurnal Keterbukaan Informasi Publik, vol. 4, no. 6, “Potret Demokrasi 2024: Antara Harapan & Fakta," Sep. 2024.
A. E. Subiyanto, “Pemilihan Umum Serentak yang Berintegritas sebagai Pembaruan Demokrasi Indonesia,” Jurnal Konstitusi, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 355–, Aug. 2020.
Zulfikhar, “Menakar Potensi Pelanggaran Kode Etik Penyelenggara Pemilu: Sebuah Analisis Teori Strukturasi,” Electoral Governance: Jurnal Tata Kelola Pemilu Indonesia, vol. 5, no. 1, 2023.
A. Amir, A. M. Iskandar, Jalal, Sriwahyuni, and M. R. Salemuddin, “Menumbuhkan Kesadaran Masyarakat Dalam Berdemokrasi,” in Konferensi Nasional Sosiologi IX APSSI, 2022.
F. Chandra, F. Yanni, and N. Gusriyani, “Hukum dan demokrasi Indonesia masa depan,” Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 1–11, 2024.
M. Harahap, R. Nadya, W. Sitanggang, and Jamaludin, “Elit politik di Indonesia: Akar dan dampak penyalahgunaan hak berdemokrasi,” Comserva: Jurnal Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat, vol. 3, no. 6, pp. 2149–2160, 2023.
Suwardi, “Kajian berpolitik berdemokrasi dalam meminimalisir konflik dalam Pilkada di Jawa Timur,” Seikat: Jurnal Ilmu Sosial, Politik dan Hukum, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 1–8, 2023.
H. Yun, J. Mishra, V. Attri, K. N. Agustyati, O. K. Hin, H. Nidham, H. Mohamed, S. Naseem, E. Davaa, B. Shrestha, S. Safdar, O. Caritos, A. Yadao, W. B. Cho, P. Amarasinghe, J. Kan, O. Nunarnan, K. Saengsurin, and C. Fonseca, Asian Electoral Review: Advancing Electoral Democracy through Electoral Reforms. Asian Network, 2024.
UNDP and UN Women, Inclusive Electoral Processes: A Guide for Electoral Management Bodies on Promoting Gender Equality and Women’s Participation” UNDP/UN Women, 2015.
G. Facal (ed.), Current Electoral Processes in Southeast Asia. Regional Learnings, Bangkok: Institut de recherche sur l’Asie du Sud-Est contemporaine (IRASEC), Nov. 2023.
